As I see it: It’s wrong for OSU to profit from climate destruction

2013-06-05T09:15:00Z As I see it: It’s wrong for OSU to profit from climate destructionBy Ken Winograd, As I see it Corvallis Gazette Times
June 05, 2013 9:15 am  • 

If a frog sits in water that gradually turns to a boil, it will not know to jump out; it doesn’t notice its imminent death until it is too late. We are the frog. It’s getting hotter and hotter, and we sit and avert our gaze from a horror just one or two degrees away. Instead, distracted by smart phones, Facebook and “Dancing with the Stars,” we are entertaining ourselves to death.

OSU Divest is a campaign to have Oregon State University Foundation sell off its investments in fossil fuels industries and replace these with investments in funds that support alternative energy. Skeptics of divestment argue that divesting fossil fuel industries out of the portfolios of universities, churches, cities, states and pension funds will reduce income for public institutions that are already pressured by diminished state funding. However, the question of divestment must be shaped by moral concerns and not the bottom line.

Our position is grounded in morality: If it is wrong to wreck the climate, then it is wrong to profit from that wreckage. Fossil fuel corporations are doing just this — profiting from the destruction of the planet in spite of a consensus of climate researchers that the current social structure is unsustainable. In order to mitigate the most dire climate scenarios, we have to change fast: to renewable energy, local and regional farms an end to profligate hyper-consumption, waste and income inequality.

It also is wrong for universities to profit from the destruction of the planet. Oregon State University, while its central mission is the affirmation of life, has inadvertently invested part of its portfolio in an industry whose bylaws legally require profits even if it means global catastrophe.

Students still look to their teachers and schools as models for how to engage as citizens in a democracy. However, when educators are silent about the most important issue to face humankind ever, students may interpret the silence to mean “There is nothing I can do; it is hopeless,” which I believe may contribute to the epidemic of anxiety and despair on American campuses today.

Responding optimistically, there are currently over 300 universities that have begun fossil fuel divestment campaigns. Divestment is just one strategy among others to address the climate crisis. The goal of divestment is to stimulate a synergy of activism, to affect a seismic shift in public opinion-that drastic changes in public policy are needed now. Not in 10 years, not in five years. Now!

Our recommendation to the OSU Foundation is the following: first, stop new investment in fossil fuels; second, over a five-year period, divest from all existing fossil fuel holdings; and, third, reinvest this portion of the portfolio in alternative energy and non-industrial food production.

The Corvallis Sustainability Coalition has helped make our community more livable. Our research faculty has done great work to study climate change and its human causes. We are proud that OSU has a national reputation for its exemplary sustainability practices. In fact, OSU is beginning to recruit students nationally because of its culture of sustainability!

However, without direct action that forces the hand of big oil, to quickly shift its resources to the development of renewable energy, the future is bleak. Divestment out of fossil fuels by our foundation is a significant symbolic action that, together with thousands of other communities looking to do the same, can make a difference. It is an action that is in our backyard, in our control. Right now, our only option is to stand up with hope and resolve!

Ken Winograd is an associate professor in the College of Education and a member of the faculty/student group, OSUDivest,

Copyright 2015 Corvallis Gazette Times. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(3) Comments

  1. curious one
    Report Abuse
    curious one - June 06, 2013 12:29 am
    And get rid of the cows and stop eating meat and drinking milk. Quit driving, stop buying gold jewelry (remember the pollution/sea grass connection), and let's remember fewer children will help!
  2. andyg
    Report Abuse
    andyg - June 05, 2013 6:57 pm
    You are being way too "reasonable" by giving OSU 5 years to divest. Divest now!
  3. ST
    Report Abuse
    ST - June 05, 2013 1:45 pm
    Thank you for this informative and well written essay. Good luck in getting OSU to divest. While it is a forward looking institution in some ways, at heart it is still a conservative bureaucracy which will be hard to budge. Sadly, opinions what is considered wise investment seem ever more polarized with the addition of oil shale, tar sands, and natural gas into the mix. I applaud your efforts.
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Activate subscription button gif

Having trouble activating? Click here for help.

where am i logo
50 Objects

Follow Us!

Events Calendar

Login or register to add your events to the calendar! Add event



The Oregon Department of Transportation is launching a test pay-as-you-drive road tax that would charge drivers 1.5 cents per mile. Do you support or oppose this alternative to the existing state and local fuel taxes to fund road maintenance?

View Results

Latest Associated Press Videos


Share Your Photos

Staff Photos

Receive Email Updates

Quick notification of big news. Delivered when news breaks (used sparingly).

Top headlines from delivered to you daily.

Get updates about the Beaver sports. Delivered 3 times a week.